×

FREE CONSULT

Learn More Services The Corporate & Financial Sector Our presence in Know About Our Team CA, CS, Corporate Lawyers & Others Our specialized team of Learn More About Us Client's Ever Changing Requirements One stop solution for

Integrity

Our essence is rooted in being honest and straight forward. We advise and advocate what we truly believe.

Wisdom

Our team and collective efforts allow free flow of information and knowledge from top to bottom and vice versa.

Togetherness

Teamwork is rooted in affluence DNA and we very much acknowledge the outcome of team work.

Confidentiality

We firmly believe that Confidentiality is the cornerstone of our Profession and strive to maintain it to the fullest possible extent.

Simplicity

We believe that the simplest solution is the best one.

Commitment

We understand only our profession and we are devoted to it. We are cent percent committed to the delivery of quality services to our clients.

About

Affluence

Explore the latest GST Update, judgments and news for January 2024! Stay updated on important developments in Goods and Service Tax to keep informed.

Kavin Hp Gas Gramin Vitrak Vs The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes(2023-VIL-896-MAD)

The issue at Hand:

In this case, a petitioner involved in the trade of Petroleum Gases encountered complications regarding the belated claim of Input Tax Credit (ITC) owing to financial constraints. The tax authorities rejected the ITC asserting that the delay in submitting GSTR-3B (tax returns) lacked a valid justification.

The petitioner contended that technical hurdles arose as the prescribed Form GSTR-2, designed for ITC claims, was not officially taken into implementation. The unavailability of the said form incapacitated the petitioner to file the claims electronically. The court acknowledged these challenges and underscored the absence of a functional mechanism for ITC claims.

Ultimately, the court overturned the tax authorities’ decisions, highlighting the unavailability of GSTR-2, which hindered electronic filing. It directed the authorities to permit manual returns and reassess ITC claims. The court emphasized the necessity of adopting a practical approach, particularly in the absence of a well-established system.

The key takeaways from this case include the struggles the petitioner faced in promptly claiming ITC due to technical issues and the non-existence of necessary forms. The court emphasized the significance of addressing practical challenges by allowing manual returns when electronic filing is not viable. The ruling underscores the need for a more accessible system for ITC claims, taking into account the real-world difficulties encountered by businesses.

The dispute pertaining to reversal of ITC in case of default in payment of tax by supplier is settled?

In the recent judgment pronounced by the Supreme Court in the case of Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Ballygunje and Others Vs Suncraft Energy Pvt. Ltd. [2023-VIL-99-SC], Apex Court dismissed the SLP filed by the department against the Calcutta High Court judgment. In this case, Calcutta HC passed an Order in favor of the assessed against which the department had gone into appeal before SC. The said decision of HC is discussed below.

Summary of HC judgment:

Suncraft Energy Private Limited and another Vs The Assistant Commissioner, State Tax, Ballygunge Charge & others [2023-VIL-487-CAL]

In this case, the department disputed the ITC claimed by the petitioner on the ground that neither the supplier’s invoices were reflected in GSTR-2A of the Appellant nor the supplier had remitted the tax collected. Petitioner in its support has submitted a copy of tax invoices along with a bank statement substantiating the payment to said vendor. Also, the petitioner submitted that the department has not conducted any inquiry on the supplier particularly when the clarification (Press release dated 18 October 2018) was issued that furnishing of outward supplies in Form GSTR-1 by the supplier and the facility to view the same in Form GSTR 2A by the recipient is in nature of taxpayer facilitation and does not impact the ability of taxpayers to avail ITC on the self-assessment basis in consonance with provisions of Section 16 of CGST Act.

Honorable High Court accepting the contention of the petitioner held that the department without resorting to any action against the supplier has completely ignored the tax invoices and bank statements submitted by the petitioner and therefore this action by the department is arbitrary. Therefore, before directing the petitioner to reverse the ITC and remit the same to the Government, the department ought to have taken action against the supplier. Hence, HC accepted the writ and held that the demand raised on the petitioner in this case is non-sustainable and to be set aside. 

Being aggrieved by this Order, the department had filed the SLP before the Apex Court.

Position after the above judgment:

In light of the above judgment, the immediate question that comes to mind is whether the issue pertaining to the reversal of ITC in case of default in payment of tax by vendor is settled. 

To answer the above, we need to consider the following positions:

  • Amendment in Section 16(2) of CGST i.e. insertion of clause (aa). In light of the same, matching of ITC with GSTR-2B is now compulsory. Therefore, the argument in the above case that GSTR-2A is merely a facilitation may not hold valid for the period post-1 January 2022. Also, for the period post 9 October 2019 onwards, wherein in light of Rule 36(4) matching of ITC with GSTR-2A became a mandatory practice, the said press release dated 18 October 2018 cannot be relied upon.
  • Another critical point to ponder upon is that the Apex Court in this case has rejected the SLP filed by the department without getting into the merits. Apex Court held that demand is on the lower side, this court is not inclined to interfere in the matter. Hence, it is plausible that a matter on similar ground is independently evaluated by Apex Court and a divergent view is taken. 
  • HC in many cases is placing reliance upon the judgment of Apex Court in the case of Ecom Gill Trading Pvt. Ltd. In the said case, Apex Court has highlighted additional details/documents that are required to be produced for substantiating the claim for ITC. The said principle is being now followed in GST with reference to Section 155 of the CGST Act for denying the ITC claim.

Hence, at this stage, it is difficult to conclude that the issue pertaining to the reversal of ITC in the case where the supplier has not remitted the tax to the Government is settled. Therefore, it will be crucial to track the positions which HC may take now in light of the above-referred judgments.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information existing at the time of preparation and we take no responsibility to update it with the subsequent changes in the law. The article is intended as a news update and Affluence Advisory neither assumes nor accepts any responsibility for any loss arising to any person acting or refraining from acting as a result of any material contained in this article. It is recommended that professional advice be taken based on specific facts and circumstances. This article does not substitute the need to refer to the original pronouncement

CLICK HERE DECEMBER GST UPDATES

Our Expertise

Our Services

  • 01
    Valuation

    Valuation opinion requires the right blend of analysis, experience and professional judgement. Our team has a Registered Valuer as required under

    Learn More
  • 02
    Due Diligence

    We provide financial, tax and corporate law due diligence support to our clients for inbound and outbound transactions.

    Learn More
  • 03
    ESOP

    ESOPs are one of the important tools to attract and retain employees and have long term career with the organization.

    Learn More
  • 04
    RBI / FEMA Compliance

    There are several compliances specified under FEMA for Indian Companies having FDI and ODI (Indian entities having investments in overseas Joint Venture

    Learn More
  • 05
    NBFC Registration and Compliances

    We carry experience of 15 years for registration of the NBCF with the RBI or carry out the process for change in management and control of the NBFC.

    Learn More
  • 06
    Fintech

    FinTech Companies are broadly categorized into digital payments or digital lending Companies. At Affluence,

    Learn More
  • 07
    Foreign Entities

    India has emerged as one of the most attractive destinations not only for investments

    Learn More
  • 08
    Company Secretarial Compliances

    We provide the entire gamut of Corporate Law Services, essential in rapidly changing regulatory and corporate environment.

    Learn More
  • 09
    SEBI Registration and Compliances

    SEBI plays an important role in regulating all the players operating in the Indian capital markets. It attempts to protect the interest of investors and aims at

    Learn More
  • 10
    Stressed Asset Resolution under IBC

    We provide advisory and support services to the corporates/other entities, devising and structuring solutions for stress mitigation in their enterprises/units.

    Learn More
  • 11
    Initial Public Offer

    On the journey of transformation of a private company into a public company, success depends a great deal on a coordinated team

    Learn More
  • 12
    Direct Tax

    The efforts of any management in modern business environment are towards enhancing a shareholder’s value. The taxes (both direct and indirect) and

    Learn More
  • 13
    Indirect Tax

    We at Affluence, adopt a comprehensive approach for implementation and compliances related to the GST and with an object to offer seamless services to our clients listed below.

    Learn More
  • 14
    Accounts Outsourcing

    In the fast-changing environment, procuring and retaining skilled staff is a challenge. Specially in the case of SMEs, in the absence of accounting manual

    Learn More
  • 15
    Risk Advisory

    Today’s businesses across the globe increasingly seek better decision-making and stronger internal controls in order to attain greater shareholder value.

    Learn More
  • 16
    Startup and MSME Advisory

    ‘Startup India’ is a flagship initiative of the Government of India, intended to catalyze startup culture and build a strong and inclusive ecosystem for innovation and

    Learn More
  • 17
    Assurance

    Assurance and accounting services are directed towards supporting stakeholders such as lenders and investors. Our standardized

    Learn More
  • 18
    Directors Due Diligence

    Director stand in a fiduciary position with the Company and Director will be held liable if Director do not act diligently in discharging his/her duties.

    Learn More

What Clients Say About Us

  • We met Affluence when they were advising Mumbai Oncocare  (our portfolio company) on their fund raise. During the course of this investment journey, we were exposed to the 360 degree approach that Affluence and CA Nimish Khakhar brought to the table which was not merely limited to due diligence and modelling but went way beyond in terms of regulatory compliances, MIS development, Finance and Account support, secretarial support and so on. We were extremely relieved and pleased with the post investment support that they continue to give to Mumbai Oncocare. We actively encourage our portfolio companies to evaluate Affluence’s service offerings and have already co-opted them with some of our other portfolio companies. Affluence does a great job of identifying gaps and help bridge the same with its committed and professional approach to the tasks that they undertake. I look forward to building on this partnership with Affluence.

    Mr. Vamesh Chovatia
    Partner, TATA CAPITAL Healthcare Fund
  • We are consulting Affluence Advisory for over 15 years for tax and compliance matters. We appreciate their competence and commitment to the engagements offered to them. Affluence’s simplified and solution-based approach is very unique and commendable. My personal best wishes to Team Affluence Advisory.

    Mr. K Ullas Kamath,
    Joint Managing Director, Jyothy Labs Ltd, Chairman – FICCI Karnataka State Council
  • We have worked with Affluence and Nimish,for well over 9 years from.From creating our companies, to handling them when they are at a multi billion dollar stage, we have found them taking care of each aspect with as much attention & perfection.
    I would go on to say, that they are one of the pillars and architects of our success and wish them the very best in everything.

    Mr. Siddharth Shah
    Co-founder, MD and CEO of Pharmeasy
We are Professional

Our Team

People are our greatest asset and we believe in our people. Our multi disciplinary team would always go that extra mile to ensure that all the client deliverables are prepared within agreed time frame to technical standards and presentational quality. Our success is greatly dependent on quality and performance of our people.

  • CA Nimish Khakhar

    Nimish Khakhar

    He is a fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. He has over 23 years of experience in Transaction (M &A) and Transaction Support Services (Vendor and Buyer side Due Diligence). His Portfolio includes both Brick and Mortar and Modern Trade Businesses. He has played key roles in a few large M & A transactions and is also been actively involved in advising Unicorns since the commencement of operations.

  • CS S. N. Baheti

    S. N. Baheti

    He is an Associate Member of the Institute of Company Secretaries of India. He has 42 years of work experience in banking and financial services (including 34 years in IDBI group), with a diversified work profile having all-round exposure to activities of Development Financial Institutions, Infrastructure Debt Fund (NBFC), Mutual Funds, Commercial Banking, NBFC-HFC, and Company Boards including MD and CEO positions and Directorships in large corporates. Presently handling assignments as Insolvency Professional. He has played a key role as RBI representative in the resolution of one of the largest NBFC transaction.

  • Sanjiv Kumar Sachdev

    Sanjiv Kumar Sachdev

    Banking professional with more than 36 years of experience in Bank and more than 25 years of experience in Project Evaluation and financing, Financial Restructuring, Resolution of Stress Accounts, Debt Syndication, Infrastructure projects, Relationship management & networking, Business development, Legal and contractual Documentation and Business Planning. During his tenure with the Bank, he had held important portfolio’s and was heading Large Corporate Group of the Bank. He also worked in Infrastructure Corporate Group for Northern Region. He was involved in various policy meetings for development of Infrastructure Projects organised by various Govt agencies and Indian Banks’ Association. He has been Chairing many consortium meetings of Lenders for Debt Syndication as well as Resolution of Stress Assets.

  • CA Dwiresh Oza

    Dwiresh Oza

    He is having 27 years of extensive professional experience in Corporate Finance, Project Finance, Private Equity, Public/Rights Issues, Due Diligence, Corporate Debt Restructuring (CDR), ERP implementation, 50:50 International Joint Venture, Closely held as well as Listed Manufacturing Accounting, Statutory/Internal/Tax Audit and knowledge of IFRS. Have worked for more than 10 years in Infrastructure, viz. Ports and roads. Have demonstrated the ability to work across teams and with the senior management and Board of Directors in achieving various strategic initiatives on a time-bound and structured approach.

  • Subhamoy Chatterjee

    Subhamoy Chatterjee

    He have experience of over 21+ years in the Banking and Financial Services Industry. He has essayed leadership roles across key functions of market advisory, treasury, relationship management, and product strategy. He expertise extends to inorganic growth through acquisitions, strategy development, and technology integration. He's successfully managed Profit and Loss centers, implemented cost-saving measures, and contributed to organizations like ICICI Bank, Standard Chartered, and Thomson Reuters.

  • CA Payal Gada

    Payal Gada

    She is a fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India and has 18 years of post-qualification experience. She is a registered valuer with IBBI as Valuation Professional and for the last 8 years, she is working on financial modeling and fair value analysis across different industries for diverse purposes, including regulatory/compliance, investment, and financial reporting. Fair valuation across asset classes including but not limited to business valuation, intangible, ESOPs, convertible instruments, and other complex instruments.

  • CA Rashmi Dubey

    Rashmi Dubey

    She is an associate member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. Over 6 years of post-qualification experience she has specialized in Risk Advisory. Her Risk Advisory experience includes internal audit, ICFR, designing of SOPs, corporate governance, enterprise risk management, internal audits.

  • CA Anand Shroff

    Anand Shroff

    He have experience of over 22+ years in Strategic Advisory and Corporate Finance. As a finance head, Anand has demonstrated the ability to work across functional teams and with the senior management and Board of Directors and achieved the organizational goals within a scheduled time through his structured approach. During his stint in the industry, Anand shouldered the responsibility of business expansion through M&A and raised capital through debts and equity. Anand has closely worked with the Promoters and took up the responsibility of execution of the entire project by coordinating with the multiple advisory agencies involved in the project. He carried this experience and assisted the Promoters with family offices set up and further advised the Promoters on domestic and overseas investments.

  • CA Hujefa Karjatwala

    Hujefa Karjatwala

    He is an associate member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India having experience of more than 12 years in profession. He specializes in Indirect Taxation & Internal audits. His area of interest includes Goods and Service Tax practice for SME clients and Internal audits.

  • CS Sachin Kotian

    Sachin Kotian

    He is a fellow member of the Institute of Company Secretaries of India. Over 15 years of experience, he has expanded his advisory and compliance services in respect of Companies Act/ SEBI / RBI / FEMA /NBFC and other Corporate Laws. Further, Research is his area of interest.

  • CS Rajeshri Kanojia

    Rajeshri Kanojia

    She is an associate member of the Institute of Company Secretaries of India with 10 years of experience in secretarial compliance and legal matters. Her forte is RBI and FEMA compliances and she is leading advisory and compliances practice of financial services which includes NBFC and Fintech Companies. Her LLB qualification gives her an edge to attend Corporate agreements and Corporate Laws.

  • CS Vinesh Mestry

    Vinesh Mestry

    He is an associated member of the Institute of Company Secretaries of India. His horizon for more than 7 years in the field of Corporate Law and adjudication-related matters before Regional Directors, NCLT. His LLB qualification gives an additional advantage in matters relating to Compounding, Mergers & Amalgamations before Regional Directors, NCLT & Other Regulatory Authorities.

  • CS Bhavesh Chheda

    Bhavesh Chheda

    He is an associated member of the Institute of Company Secretaries of India. He has experience of more than 8 years and focuses on BSE and NSE Listed Companies and SEBI and Corporate Governance related matters. He also supports the compliance team in respect of Companies Act / RBI / FEMA / Corporate law.

  • CS Tanvi Shah

    Tanvi Shah

    She is an associate member of the Institute of Company Secretaries of India. Over 5 years of post-qualification experience, she focuses on Compliances of Companies Act/RBI/ and NBFC.

  • CS Garima Mandhania

    Garima Mandhania

    She is an associate member of the Institute of Companies Secretaries of India. She has an experience of 3 years and she focuses on Secretarial compliance, NBFC, and Listed Compliances.

  • CS Ritik Madnani

    Ritik Madnani

    He is an associate member of the Institute of Company Secretaries of India. Over 2.5 years of experience in corporate laws, he focuses on Compliances of Companies Act/RBI/ NBFC/LLP Act/ SEBI etc.

  • CA Ambarish Sodha

    Ambarish Sodha

    He is a fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. Over 43 years in direct tax litigation and tax advisory services, he appears before first and second appellate authorities. Over and above Profession, he is actively engaged in several social causes including promoting girls’ education in rural areas.

  • CA Payal Khakhar

    Payal Khakhar

    She is a fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. She has experience with over two decades. She heads indirect tax practice that covers regular GST compliances, GST reviews, and advisory services across different sectors.

  • CA Tejas Sodha

    Tejas Sodha

    He is a fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. He handles Direct tax litigation and compliance for over 12 years and regularly appears before first and second appellate authorities. He advises NRI on direct tax and withholding tax matters. His involvement in complex tax structuring has been appreciated by the Clients.

  • CA Dipesh Sangoi

    Dipesh Sangoi

    He is a fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. He heads Assurance practice and handles listed as well as unlisted companies and MNCs over the last 15 years. He manages Statutory Audits, Bank Audits - Central Statutory and Branch Audits, and Certification work for obtaining Bank Finance and certificates required for Public Issues.

  • CA Payal Doshi

    Payal Doshi

    She is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. Her 10 years of experience is channelized towards Statutory Audits of Listed as well as unlisted entities and Tax Audits and Certification work.

  • CA Viral Shah

    Viral Shah

    He is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. He has experience of more than 7 years and he is involved in Statutory Audits of Listed as well as Unlisted entities and Tax Audits and Bank Audits.

  • CA Ritesh Jain

    Ritesh Jain

    He is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. He is engaged in compliance and management support functions. His industry experience contributes significantly to his delivery.

  • CA Aakash Sarda

    Aakash Sarda

    He is a qualified Chartered Accountant having an experience of over 7 years in Indirect Taxation. He has worked with Deloitte in the Indirect Taxation team for over 5 years. He has handholded clients with Service Tax, VAT/CST, GST compliances, advisory, refunds, department audits, inquiries and investigations by intelligence wings of the department and litigation matters. He also holds experience in conducting Anti-Profiteering study. He has assisted in preparing a representation for Gems & Jewellery sector on GST concessions sought by them. Further, he holds experience with SEZ related matters such as setting up a unit in SEZ area, their monthly compliances and advising them on their business transactions. His experience also covers the examination of agreements and evaluates the GST impact of the transaction under consideration. He has provided various opinions through Memo/Notes on issues specific to clients business and industry wide issues. He has served clients like General Insurance, Internet Telecommunication, Information Technology, Hospitality sectors etc. among others.

  • Adv Dhruti Shah

    Dhruti Shah

    She is an attorney practising in taxation matters. She had represented clients before High Court, Debt Recovery Tribunals, City Civil Court and various other forums. She holds experience in handling GST advisory, compliances, returns, computation of tax & it's payment thereof and maintaining audit trials & reports for assistance with assessments. She has served clients in various sectors viz-a-viz Banking, Information Technology, Education, Gaming & Entertainment.