Off Market transfer of shares without consideration is not allowed – SEBI

Facts of the case:

  • SEBI conducted an investigation into the trading in the scrip of Shrestha Finvest Ltd [‘Company’]. SEBI observed that Mrs. Renu Bhushan, (Noticee no.1), Mr Bharath Bhushan, (Noticee no. 2) and Mr Brij Bhushan, Noticee no. 3 [Noticees] had dealt in the shares of SRL.
  • SEBI observed that there was an off-market transfer of 10,00,000 shares of SFL between Mrs Renu and Mr Bharat of 10,00,000 shares of SRL on March 29, 2017 and also there was transfer of 10,00,000 shares of SRL between Mr. Brij and Mr. Bharat Bhushan on February 22, 2018. Upon perusal of the Delivery Instruction Slip (DIS) slip in respect of the aforesaid off market transaction, it was observed that it contained a remark ‘collateral returned’.
  • On further analysis, it was observed that Mr. Bharat Bhushan received 10,00,000 shares of the scrip of SFL from Mrs. Renu Bhushan (Connected entity to Mr. Brij Bhushan as both Brij Bhushan and Mrs. Renu Bhushan have same email id and phone number for placing orders) on March 29, 2017. Mrs Renu Bhushan further contented that she did not knew Mr Bharat Bhushan. She further stated that her husband Mr Brij Bhushan was discussing some business deal with Mr Bharat Bhushan and in support of that as a collateral security SRL shares were provided. Since the business deal did not fructify my husband have requested Mr Bharat Bhushan to return the collateral provided. She further stated that under a bonafide belief Mr Brij Bhushan inadvertently provided Mr Bharat Bhushan details of his own Demat account and the collateral was returned to his account on 22-02-18. Mr Brij Bhushan reiterated the submission of his wife Ms Renu Bhushan.
  • Mr. Bharat Bhushan. In response, vide reply dated June 18, 2021, submitted “shares were returned to Brij Bhushan account which were earlier taken for collateral purpose for business. As business deal did not go thru these were returned. He further stated that there was no purchase or sale transaction w.r.t. the said shares of SFL as it was for collateral purpose, which is also mentioned on DIS. Shares transferred for collateral purpose and returned thereafter, cannot be alleged to be shares purchased and sold.
  • SEBI alleged this as a change of ownership of the shares. In this regard SEBI observed that there was no fund settlement done by Mr. Bharat Bhushan with Mr. Brij Bhushan or Ms. Renu Bhushan for the aforementioned off market transactions.
  • SEBI further sought details regarding off market transfer from depository participant CDSL. CDSL, in its response submitted to SEBI that no pledge was initiated by Mr. Bharat Bhushan or Mr. Brij Bhushan for the aforesaid off market transaction dated February 22, 2018.
  • In view of the above, SEBI alleged that the aforementioned off market transaction cannot be treated as collateral. Further, it is alleged that while there was a change in the ownership of the shares of SFL in this context and as there was no fund transaction/settlement done, Mr. Brij Bhushan, Ms. Renu Bhushan and Mr. L Bharat Bhushan in this regard, violated the provisions of Section 2 (i) (a) read with Section 13, 16, 18 of the SCRA and SEBI notification dated October 03, 2013 issued under the sections 16 and 28 of the SCRA.

Question of law framed by SEBI:  Whether the Noticees entered into off market transactions without making payment of consideration/fund settlement during the investigation period and hence, violated the provisions of Section 2 (i) (a) read with Section 13, 16, 18 of the SCRA and SEBI notification dated October 03, 2013 issued under the Sections 16 and 28 of the SCRA?

Reply by SEBI:

  • SEBI stated that the off-market transactions entered into by the Noticees, are governed by the provisions of SCRA i.e. Section 2 (i) (a) read with Section 13, 16, 18 of the SCRA and SEBI notification dated October 03, 2013 issued under the sections 16 and 28 of the SCRA which provide that whenever there is actual delivery of securities payment of price therefor shall be made either on same day or on next day. It also states that transfer of shares in a manner other than this will not be considered as ‘Spot Delivery Contract’.
  • Referring to this provision SEBI stated that in respect of receipt of 10,00,000 shares from Mrs. Renu Bhushan on March 29, 2017, Mr. Bharath Bhushan was mandated to make payment to Mrs. Renu Bhushan either on the same day i.e. on March 29, 2017 or on the next day i.e. on March 30, 2017. SEBI further noted that in respect of receipt of 10,00,000 shares from Mr. Bharath Bhushan on February 22, 2018, Mr. Brij Bhushan was mandated to make payment to Mr. Brij Bhushan either on the same day i.e. on February 22, 2018 or on the next day i.e. on February 23, 2018. However, in both scenarios, the Noticees have not made payment of consideration/fund settlement with each other. This fact was accepted by the Noticees that no fund settlement took place for the said transactions
  • SEBI perused submission of Noticees. SEBI highlighted that Mrs. Renu, Mr. Brij and Mr. Bharath have not provided any supporting document/valid business agreements to substantiate the submissions made by them as regards the ‘business proposal’ entered into by them. In the absence of any legitimate agreements for using the shares as ‘collateral’ for business purposes, the aforesaid submissions of the Noticee nos. 1 and 3 cannot be accepted.
  • SEBI further highlighted that Delivery Instruction Slip (DIS) was obtained from the DP in respect of the off market transaction dated February 22, 2018 entered into by the Mr. Bharath Bhushan and Mr. Brij Bhushan. Upon perusal of the said DIS slip it was noted that the remarks column on DIS stated as ‘collateral returned’. SEBI noted that no pledge was initiated but that in the absence of valid business agreements the off market transactions of the Noticees cannot be considered as ‘collateral’ even though the term ‘collateral’ was mentioned on the DIS slip.
  • Admittedly the Noticees also failed to make the payment of consideration in respect of the off market transactions entered into by them, within the stipulated time, the details of which were already discussed in the previous paragraphs.
  • In this regard SEBI referred to various Hon ‘able Supreme Court cases viz. SEBI vs Opee Stock Link Ltd dt: July 11, 2016 whereby it held that, “We also note that the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (SCRA) has been enacted to prevent undesirable transactions in securities by regulating the business of dealing therein, by providing for certain other matters connected therewith like regulating functioning of recognised stock exchanges and working of the members of such stock exchanges. The SCRA is a special law to regulate the sale and purchase of shares and securities and hence it prevails over the provisions of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 and Sale of Goods Act, 1930, insofar as the matters which are specifically dealt with by the SCRA. The contracts for sale and purchase of securities, as envisaged under the SCRA, can be entered into only in a prescribed manner in a notified area and that can only be effected through registered members of a recognised stock exchange (i.e. stock brokers) and the only exception to this is a Spot Delivery Contract…”.
  • Accordingly, SEBI held that Section 2(i)(b) of the SCRA was introduced in the statute book with effect from September 20, 1995. It is clear from the aforestated definition of ‘Spot Delivery Contract’ that to enter into such a contract, the seller has to effect actual delivery of securities and the buyer has to pay the price therefor either on the same day or on the next day and further, the said transfer should be coupled with transfer of the Securities from one Beneficial Owner (BO) to another.




Violation established

Penal provision

Noticee no.1/ Mrs. Renu Bhushan

Rs 100,000

Section 2 (i) (a) read with Sections 13, 16, 18 of the SCRA and SEBI notification dated October 03, 2013 issued under the Sections 16 and 28 of the SCRA.

Section 23H of SCRA

Noticee no.1/ Mrs. Renu Bhushan

Rs 150,000

Noticee no.3/ Mr. Brij Bhushan

Rs 100,000

Click here to Download PDF

Disclaimer:This article provides general information existing at the time of preparation and we take no responsibility to update it with the subsequent changes in the law. The article is intended as a news update and Affluence Advisory neither assumes nor accepts any responsibility for any loss arising to any person acting or refraining from acting as a result of any material contained in this article. It is recommended that professional advice be taken based on specific facts and circumstances. This article does not substitute the need to refer to the original pronouncement



Affluence Advisory Pvt. Ltd. is established with the vision to provide one stop solutions to clients needs in ever changing environment. Affluence is managed by specialized team of Chartered Accountants, Company Secretaries, Corporate Lawyers and Other Professionals committed to provide quality experience to our clients in the widest spectrum of business needs.

Recent Posts

April 1st, 2023
SEBI has approved following amendments in its Board Meeting
March 27th, 2023
Common and simplified norms for processing investor’s service requests by RTA’s and norms for furnishing PAN, KYC details and Nomination
March 23rd, 2023
Additional affirmations by Practicing Company Secretaries (PCS) in Annual Secretarial Compliance Report
March 20th, 2023
Peer to Peer (P2P) Lending in India
March 17th, 2023
Regulatory Framework – Liability of Independent Director
March 15th, 2023
Social Stock Exchange (SSE) – Fund Raising Platform for “Not for Profit Organizations” (NPO)
March 13th, 2023
MSME Registration Benefits – Tax and Others
March 10th, 2023
Link PAN with Aadhaar by March 31: SEBI direction to Investors
March 8th, 2023
Importance of Credit Score
March 6th, 2023
Closure Of The Company – Various Exit Modes Of Voluntary Winding Up
March 2nd, 2023
FAQ’s on Social Stock Exchange
March 2nd, 2023
Latest Key Amendments Effective from April 01, 2023
February 25th, 2023
Consultation Paper On Strengthening Corporate Governance At Listed Entities By Empowering Shareholders – Amendments To The SEBI (LODR) Regulations, 2015
February 24th, 2023
National Pension System (NPS) – Additional Tax Saving Option
February 20th, 2023
Tax Deduction and Documentation for Salary – AY 2023-24
February 13th, 2023
SEBI Consultation paper on review of Corporate Governance norms for a High-Value Debt Listed Entity dated February 08, 2023
February 9th, 2023
SEBI revamps buyback methods and provisions relating to buybacks
February 7th, 2023
SEBI circular on achieving min public shareholding
February 3rd, 2023
Off Market transfer of shares without consideration is not allowed – SEBI
February 2nd, 2023
Informal Guidance to proposed to be listed company – Extending share based employee benefits to employees of a subsidiary company
February 1st, 2023
Generating Awareness on the availability of Disputes Resolution Mechanisms at Stock Exchanges against Listed Companies / Registrar to an Issue and Share Transfer Agent
January 30th, 2023
Remuneration paid to Directors of the Listed Entity – Series 3
January 25th, 2023
Upgradation of E- Forms in tune with V3 portal
January 23rd, 2023
SEBI Notification dated 17/01/23 | Securities and Exchange Board of India (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) (Amendment) Regulations, 2023
January 19th, 2023
Remuneration paid to Non-Executive Directors of Public Company – Series 2
January 16th, 2023
Remuneration paid to Whole Time Directors of Public unlisted Companies
January 11th, 2023
Relaxation from compliance with certain provisions of the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015
January 9th, 2023
Online registration of units through MCA portal for ESI registration and inspection of units in this regard
January 6th, 2023
Guidance given by Securities and Exchange Board of India (‘SEBI’) on creation of ‘Suspense Escrow Demat Account’
January 5th, 2023
Change in Single Master Form (SMF) on FIRMS Portal
January 3rd, 2023
Relaxation with respect to conducting of Extra Ordinary General Meetings and Postal Ballots
December 30th, 2022
MCA extension for conducting Annual General Meetings through Video Conferencing or other Audio Visual Means (‘OAVM’)
December 23rd, 2022
Web-based Form DPT-3 as per New Rules
December 13th, 2022
Input Tax Credit (‘ITC’) on Corporate Social Responsibility (‘CSR’) expenses
December 7th, 2022
GSTR 9 and 9C – Optional to Mandatory reporting in FY 2021-22
September 27th, 2022
CSR Compliances as per New Rules 2022
September 20th, 2022
Mandatory appointment of Company Secretary
September 17th, 2022
Amendment To The Definition Of Small Company And Benefits
September 16th, 2022
Obligation to Indicate Director Identification Number (DIN)
September 7th, 2022
RBI issues Digital Lending Guidelines: Banks / NBFC